The Qur’an Cannot Be A Text of Divine Origin

[محمد سني 1989]

Quote

I didn't say it did.. Read my post I said not all early Jewish literature was considered inspired by God, and gave the apocrypha as an example. I was making a general point.

Clearly you haven't since your response was based on explaining that the phrase hebrew literuture which pulpit used could have reffered to non OT documents like talmud , midrash or the apocryphatic texts , which is not true at all since its within the context of explaining the passage , pulpit used it to refer to the OT

Quote

I'm sorry but why are you bringing the Gospels into the equation? We are talking of the Jewish Torah are we not... Christians know quite well what was added to the Gospels and can give a pretty good idea of when it occurred. That's why your post about the ending of Mark which seems to have perturbed you some what has not been addressed.. It's old news.

WRONG pandora!!!!! WRONG

Either you have ignored my response or just quickly skimmed to it , I have already mentioned two other examples relating to the OT
more importantly you said the bible so need to play such games

Quote

numbers are immaterial unless you are simply going to go with the consensus of opinion I guess. Allow me to share another observation on books with you... All books or articles written to an audience are can never be truly unbiased... The author will always have his/her agenda. Target audience..profit.. Or simply making a name for themselves on the stage of academia

WRONG!!! .....AGAIN pandora

Yet again you have proved to everybody that you are avoiding admitting the truth and trying to twist and manipulate the basic understanding

The christian commentray sources which I have cited are just two examples of CHRISTIAN INTERPRITATION , which all have the same opinion about the passage , the fact that a christian author of an article ON A MUSLIM-CHRISTIAN DEBATE website would defer shows either a personal opinion to avoid admitting what the muslim claim or just simply being dishonest !!!!

So again you are trying to avoid the bias in the article you copied and pasted by holding on to the technicality that all articles and books are bias!!!!!

BTW I already cited many jewish and christian sources which shows that the prophet and his followers were from Ishmael here:

http://www.ebnmaryam.com/vb/t200780.html

Quote

you have pretty much misunderstood everything I have posted. I think we are done here.. Don't you?

Tell that to yourself

peace