There are SERIOUS problems with the fundamental methods Pandora and Burnlight argue .
First of all Pandora , what is it that you are dissapointed for ? If we put the sarcastic title of the thread and the way it was presented aside , what is there for you to be upset about ? The point of it is mentioning a number of negative aspects ascribed to the prophets in the Bible . We don't believe in them of course but you do . So you're supposed to deny that they exist in the Bible - can't see that happening with such clear quotes - , demonstrate that they are true but NOT negative aspects , admit that they are negative aspects because - as I heard from you two MANY times - prophets are not sinless , OR admit that this can't be of a divine source .
No need to say we'll disagree with any of the three points I mentioned and make our own countering arguments but the problem here is that not even one of them was made .
As for Burnlight , I'm not sure if he's banned completely or temporally . Not sure what happened exactly but I'll trust my brothers and sisters for the time being since I know his method . When we look at his argument , if he tries to patch a place , another one is exposed ! Here he claims that the Bible isn't directly revelaed by Allah but rather by men inspired from him . Aside from the fact that there's a number of those men we don't know so far , HOW do you know that they didn't alter a thing ? Are you saying that they mentioned false things which differ from reality or what ?! If that's the case , that is a HUGE problem for Christians ! So I hope you or Pandora explain clearly . I'll repeat what I told Pandora . This thread mentions a number of negative aspects you ascribe to the prophets peace upon them . So , from what you're saying , you either don't deny that they are true and thus these negative aspects are indeed associated with the ones supposed to deliver the message - A huge problem by itself ! - or that they are not and that the writers wrote false things - intentionally or not - which differ from reality and presented them as the message of the lord . BOTH are great issues which cannot be ignored . So am I missing something ?
Don't you notice that everything you accuse Islam of actually exist in the book you believe in ? So who's throwing rocks on others while his house is made of glass ? There was a topic which title partially says "Don't object" and it lists a load of such examples but I can't seem to find it .
Reply With Quote
Bookmarks