Second:
The evidence of their suspicion is the narration by Jabber (Allah be pleased with him)he told: I said: O the Prophet of Allah tell me about the first thing Allah had created before anything else? The Prophet (Allah bless him and grant him peace) said: “O Jabber Allah the Almighty created Light of your prophet from his light before anything else ….” The evidence if false and not serving their interests in any way; because the narration is fabricated about our prophet (Allah bless him and grant him peace) and we do not recognize it; thus spoke about it venerable scholars like:
1-Al Shaikh Al Albani (Allah grant mercy upon his soul) commented on the correct hadith in Correct Series number 458 "Angels are created from Light, Satan from scorching fire and Adam from what described to you".
His (Allah grant mercy upon his soul) comment was:
In it there is an indication of falseness of the widespread hadith between the people:" the first thing created was your Prophet's Light O Jabber" and other related hadiths which narrate that the Prophet ((Allah bless him and grant him peace) was created from Light, this hadith is a clear evidence that only angles are created from Light, excluding Adam and his children, so be careful and do not be of the unaware people.
And about what Abdullah Ibn Ahmad narrated in (Al Sunna) page 151 from Akrama, said:
"Angels are created from Light of glory and satan is created from faire of glory".
And Abdullah Ibn Amro said: "Allah has created the angels from the Light of arms and chest".
I said : all of those are from Israel and it is not allowed to take, cause it is not narrated from the honest and trustworth (Allah bless him and grant him peace) .
2- Al Shekh Abu Al Fith Ahmad Al Gumary said in his book (A raid on Fabricated Hadiths in the Little Collection ): it is a fabricated hadith, if it was mentioned with perfection who stated it as fabricated would not stop at it, and the rest of it is put on about two big pieces of pages including weak expressions and denied meanings.
3- Shekh Rashid Ritha said in his advisory opinions (fatawa) 2/447:
This hadith has no base, and Al Siwty said this before, was asked about this hadith, as in Al Hawi for Advisory Opinions (Fatawa) chapter 1 page 323, he said: the mentioned hadith in the question has no reference to depend on . thus finalized. Allah knows the best.
So from what previously mentioned: what is used as evidence is untrue and nor serving the objectors. in the bounty of Allah the Almighty.