Refuting the suspicion:
First:
This narration is denied from both of rational side and narrating side, rationally the logic is completely refusing this issue; cause dog decays after he dies, and a bad smelling rises ….
And from narrating side this narrative or story is denied by the Muslim scholars and they don’t recognize is as correct one, as what follows :
1-Ibn Hajar (Allah bless his soul) said in Al Fateh (chapter 14/ page 122): Now I found in Al Tabarani with a prediction it is stated in it that who don’t know the reason of revelation was a puppy under Prophet’s (peace be upon him) bed and he did not feel it so the Gabriel did not come to him because of this, the story of Gabriel’s interrupt because of a dog under the bed is famous , but to be the reason for revealing this verse is very strange, but even odd, and it is refused by what is in the correct and Allah know best.
2- Al Sheikh Al Albani (Allah bless him) said in the (Serial of Weak) number 6136 (denied) O Khawla, what happened in the Messenger of Allah’s house? Gabriel is not coming to me! Was there an event happened in the house of the Messenger of Allah?... O Khawla cover me!
Allah revealed : By the morning brightness (1) And [by] the night when it covers with darkness, (2) Your Lord has not taken leave of you, [O Muhammad], nor has He detested . (3)
Al Tabarani said in (The Great Dictionary) (24/249/636) Ali Ibn Abdulaziz said to us : Abw Naaeh repeated, Hfs Bin Saaed Alquraishy repeated, from her mother my mother narrated to me : a puppy had entered the house, went under the bed and died, days passed and no revelation came to the Messenger of Allah (peace be upon him) he said: (he narrated the hadith), I said: I swear by Allah we never had a day more blessing than today he took his garment wore it and went outside I said : if I prepare the house for sweeping it and I tried to sweep under the bed by sweeper there was something heavy; I tried with it till a dead puppy came out I took it with my hands and threw it outside behind the wall so the Prophet come home and his beard was trembling –usually whenever the revelation came to him (peace be upon him) trembling took hold of him – and said : “O Khawla cover me” …. The hadith.
And Ibn Abi Shiba in his (Masnad), from him Ibn Abi Assim in Last “Al Ahad wal mathani”, and from him Ibn Atheer in “The Lion of the forest” (6/94) Abu Naeem Al Fatheel Bin Dkeen narrated for us : ….. . thus.
I said : this is a weak predication, and has two faults , which are unawareness:
First : Um Hfs Bin Saeed: I did not find her biography , and thus Al Haithamee find fault; and said in “Al Majmah” (7/138): “Al Tabarani narrated it, Um Hfs I did not know her”.
3- Sheikh Salim Al Hilaly and Sheikh Muhammad Al Nasir (Allah bless them) in the Book of Comprehension (3/523): weak.
Reply With Quote
Bookmarks