نضيفلك كمان شوية
[IMG]http://files.ar*************/upload/images2011/1033997487.png[/IMG]
[SIZE="6"][COLOR="Blue
As with verse 9 there is far more reason to think that the Book of Enoch was copied from Jude than vice versa.

“How, then, would Jude have learned of this ancient prophecy?” one might ask. By verbal inspiration! And to even ask such a question demonstrates one’s doubt of that very doctrine and his reliance upon human reason.

It should be crystal clear, therefore, that saying Jude quoted from the Book of Enoch is not only an “unwarranted assumption,

Coder, p. 85.


[The Book of Enoch] has every mark of having been written subsequent to the destruction of Jerusalem [and therefore after Jude’s Epistle was written], by a Jew who still buoyed himself up with the hope that God would stand by the Jews


William Kelly, “Lectures on the Epistle of Jude,” The Serious Christian, Vol. I (Charlotte, NC: Books for Christians, 1970), as cited in William MacDonald, Believer’s Bible Commentary (Nashville: Thomas Nelson Publishers, 1995), p. 2343.