( By the heaven and the Tarik (The Knocker) Ah, what will tell thee what the Tarik (The knocker) is! The piercing Star )
the holy Qura'n 86:1-3
1- The Knocker 's sound :
The piercing Star:
now the question is :
who tell the prophet Muhammad PUH about these scientific facts 1400 years ago ?????
Firstly, I'm impressed by your and other ability to read into what appears to be quite ambiguous verses from the Quran such in depth knowledge of astronomy.
Secondly, as the verses aren't exactly clear and I'm sure would be not be given serious consideration as scientific fact by any scientist today.
Thirdly... As there was a wealth of information on science in general... Including astronomy.. Long before the 6th century.. The possibility exists that if the chance exists somewhere in the world that knowledge was available.. Then you cannot rule out with any certainty that it was seen by people in Arabia during the lifetime of the prophet of I slam. Would you have us believe prophet Mohammed never left his home or interacted with other people... Some possibly well educated and well travelled.
the ancient Greeks were way ahead of the game in regards to science..the gospels had spread from Greece to Arabia before the 6th century so we know knowledge travelled.. I'm not saying prophet Mohammed came by information this way.. But he could have done.
Fourthly.. Personally ..these claims of scientific accuracy as some kind of proof of divinity of the Quran don't count for much. I am looking for spiritual guidance from scripture.. There are many "scientific" proofs also found in the Bible... Again I don't attach as much importance to them as I do to its spiritual guidance.
Originally Posted by *اسلامي عزي*
Reply With Quote
Bookmarks