السلام عليكم و رحمة الله و بركاته
وجدت ملحداً يسأل هذا السؤال في الyahoo answers
و أحببت أن اسمع ردودكم قبل أن أرد عليه
Christians, Muslims, and Jews: Do you believe God created Adam and Eve perfect or imperfect?
According to your beliefs, the supposed "fall of man" occurredin the garden of eden when adam and eve ate the forbidden fruit. In a previous question, I asked how could've Adam and Eve eaten the apple if they were God's original "perfect" humans because if they were truly perfect, they wouldn't of ate the fruit in the first place. However, many thiest objected by arguing that Adam and Eve weren't actually perfect; rather, they argued that they were simply "sinless" until the point they ate the apple.
So if God created Adam and Eve imperfect, weren't they already bound to commit some sort of sin anyway even if they had never ate the fruit at all? Also, if God knew they were imperfect why did he permit the fruit-tree to be in the garden to begin with?
ملاحظة: اظن أني وضعت الموضوع في القسم الخاطئ أرجو من الادارة نقله الى القسم المناسب
و جزاكم الله خير الجزاء
و السلام عليكم و رحمة الله و بركاته